Here’s Why the London Stock Exchange is Facing Profitability Challenges

The Current State of the UK’s Stock Market

Policymakers, regulators, and prominent figures in the City are all focused on revitalizing the UK stock market.
The challenges are twofold: companies are disappearing, and new entrants are insufficient to compensate for these losses.

The market is contracting at such a pace that the UK risks losing its status as Europe’s top financial hub, raising concerns about a terminal decline.
This phenomenon is driven by multiple factors, with a significant belief that UK stocks are trading at a discount compared to their international counterparts becoming increasingly entrenched.

Market Composition and IPO Activity

There are valid reasons for this sentiment.
For instance, the FTSE 100 index is dominated by sectors with low ratings, such as resources and banking, while lacking high-rated technology stocks.

An increasing number of companies choosing to leave the London market for the United States has bolstered the perception of the UK as a discounted market.
However, IPO activity is showing signs of revival; the recent success of Raspberry Pi’s listing, followed by the debut of a new investment vehicle from Melrose’s founders, highlights this trend.
Foreign listings may also follow, including fast-fashion giant Shein and French broadcaster Canal+.

Market Valuation Insights

Despite these positive developments, the perceived discount within the market remains significant.
The FTSE All-Share index is trading at just 11 times future earnings, reflecting a nearly 40% discount compared to other developed market stock exchanges.
This disparity is largely attributed to the surge of tech stocks in the US amid an artificial intelligence frenzy.

While the discount is hard to overlook, James Arnold, who leads UBS’s strategic analysis team, argues that the critical question is whether the UK systematically undervalues equity capital—his firm belief is that it does not.
He points to a strong correlation between stock valuations, based on price to gross asset value, and profitability, measured by cash flow return on investment.

With an R-squared of 80% for the Stoxx 600 index, this relationship explains much of the divergence in corporate valuations across the US, UK, and EU markets.
This suggests that the UK’s lower stock valuations compared to US counterparts are predominantly rooted in lower average profitability.

Ultimately, this disparity highlights a management issue rather than a market flaw, although Arnold acknowledges that the UK’s excessive focus on dividends over growth and its consequent risk aversion exacerbate the situation.
Addressing these core challenges should be London’s next priority.

© The Financial Times Limited 2024.
All rights reserved.
Redistribution, copying, or modification in any form is prohibited.

The Financial Times does not guarantee the accuracy or quality of this translation.
Money.it has limited republishing rights for some Financial Times articles.
This is not a real-time feed of Financial Times content.